J.K. Rowling was accused of anti-Semitism because of goblins running Gringotts Bank

Juliette Morgan
J.K. Rowling was accused of anti-Semitism because of goblins running Gringotts Bank

American comedian and TV presenter Jon Stewart accused writer J.K. Rowling of anti-Semitism — in the last episode of his podcast The Problem With Jon Stewart, he drew attention to the fact that in the Harry Potter books, goblins running the Gringotts bank are similar in description to caricature Jews.

When I talk to people, I often ask them: "Have you watched the Harry Potter movies? Have you seen the scenes at Gringotts Bank? Do you know who these guys who run the bank are? Jews!"

Stewart pointed out that when he showed his interlocutors an illustration from the 1903 anti-Semitic book "Protocols of the Elders of Zion", they often believed that it depicted a scene from "Harry Potter".

And they're like, "Oh, it's a picture from a Harry Potter book!". And you say to them: "No, this is a caricature of a Jew from anti-Semitic literature." <...> This is the world of magic and sorcery. There you can fly dragons, get an owl as a pet. But who will run the bank? Jews. Unless we make their teeth sharper.

The 59-year-old comedian added that he did not expect such indifference from society to what he himself immediately drew attention to.

When I saw it on the screen, I thought that people would be outraged that everyone would say: "Oh shit, did she really do that, in the world of magic, to force Jews to run a fucking underground bank." And everyone waved them off, they say, they're just magicians. It was so weird.

J.K. Rowling has been accused of anti-Semitism before because of the Gringotts goblins. But there were also those who spoke out in her defense. So, the writer Dan Kahan in an article for PopDust noticed: 

The goblins of Gringotts really look like stereotypical Jews in the minds of anti-Semites. But surely Rowling didn't do it intentionally. In addition, there are many borrowings from folklore and other fantasy stories in her Harry Potter books. So the anti-Semitic features of goblins rather refer to how bankers were portrayed in fantasy. It just so happened that they were probably inspired by anti-Jewish propaganda.

At the moment, the writer is also at the center of a scandal due to accusations of transphobia, which is why she was not invited to shoot in the special episode "Harry Potter 20 years later: Return to Hogwarts".

More in the section Celebrity

Celebrity

The Godfather and Apocalypse Now star Robert Duvall has died.

He was 95 years old.

Celebrity

70-year-old former Google CEO Eric Schmidt is suspected of having an affair with the Prime Minister's daughter, who is 43 years his junior.

The married billionaire's new romance is being discussed online.

Celebrity

Kirsten Dunst with her husband, Kaia Gerber in a nude dress, Kate Hudson and Ernest Hemingway's great-granddaughter at the Independent Spirit Awards

Celebrities attended the film awards.

Celebrity

Pamela Anderson, Dua Lipa in a nude dress and with her fiancé attended the Berlin Film Festival.

Stars took to the red carpet at the Berlinale.

Celebrity

Meghan Markle and Prince Harry went to a basketball game

The couple made a public appearance in California.

Celebrity

Hailey Bieber (in vintage), Rosie Huntington-Whiteley, Jacob Elordi, and Rita Ora at the Vogue Gala

Justin Bieber's wife and Jason Statham's girlfriend were the stars of the event.

Celebrity

Royal decorator commits suicide after criticism from Charles III

The body of the deceased was found in the courtyard of his house.

Celebrity

Beyoncé changed her look after being mistaken for her 14-year-old daughter.

Beyoncé changed her haircut for the first time in a long time.

Celebrity

"Stunned." Gigi Hadid responded to ex-boyfriend Zayn Malik's claims that he never loved her.

The singer broke an agreement not to discuss his relationship with the model publicly.

Celebrity

51-year-old Penelope Cruz posed in leather and micro shorts for a glossy magazine.

The actress graced the cover of the magazine.

Celebrity

The Godfather and Apocalypse Now star Robert Duvall has died.

Celebrity

70-year-old former Google CEO Eric Schmidt is suspected of having an affair with the Prime Minister's daughter, who is 43 years his junior.

Celebrity

Kirsten Dunst with her husband, Kaia Gerber in a nude dress, Kate Hudson and Ernest Hemingway's great-granddaughter at the Independent Spirit Awards

Celebrity

Pamela Anderson, Dua Lipa in a nude dress and with her fiancé attended the Berlin Film Festival.

Celebrity

Meghan Markle and Prince Harry went to a basketball game

Celebrity

Hailey Bieber (in vintage), Rosie Huntington-Whiteley, Jacob Elordi, and Rita Ora at the Vogue Gala

Celebrity

Royal decorator commits suicide after criticism from Charles III

Celebrity

Beyoncé changed her look after being mistaken for her 14-year-old daughter.

Celebrity

"Stunned." Gigi Hadid responded to ex-boyfriend Zayn Malik's claims that he never loved her.

Celebrity

51-year-old Penelope Cruz posed in leather and micro shorts for a glossy magazine.

Celebrity

Kate Hudson in a fur coat, Julia Fox in a hat, Taylor Momsen and Teyana Taylor attended fashion events

Celebrity

Where to meet a promising man: from padel to a philosophy circle

Celebrity

It's February 13th: 20 Cool Valentine's Day Cards You Can Still Give

Celebrity

Gwyneth Paltrow's daughter Apple posed for Vogue and said she dreams of becoming an actress.

Celebrity

"He's insanely jealous." Kanye West's feelings on his ex-wife Kim Kardashian's new romance have been revealed.

Celebrity

Kate Middleton visited a primary school in London in a pantsuit.

Celebrity

Hailey Bieber in a nude dress, Margot Robbie, Jacob Elordi at the Wuthering Heights premiere in Sydney

Celebrity

"You're a fucking stupid bitch." Married Shia LaBeouf's mistress accused him of abuse and death threats.

Celebrity

Måneskin frontman Damiano David and his girlfriend (in a "bride dress") stepped out after their engagement.

Celebrity

Jennifer Aniston's boyfriend shared a photo of their kiss in honor of her 57th birthday.