Harry Styles debuts 'What Is Enough' at MSG in moving Liam Payne tribute

Celebrity & Entertainment journalist
Harry Styles performing live on stage during his Together, Together tour
Harry Styles performing on the Together, Together tour Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0

Harry Styles marked the second anniversary of Liam Payne's death with a song nobody had heard before. On Friday night at Madison Square Garden, he introduced “What Is Enough,” an unreleased acoustic track, to a sold-out crowd during his Together, Together residency. Fans were hearing the song for the first time — not as a streaming release, but as a tribute played live.

Styles is in the middle of an MSG run that continues through October 31. Two years to the day since Payne died at 31 after falling from a balcony at the CasaSur Palermo Hotel in Buenos Aires, Argentina, he paused the show to address the packed room.

“I feel incredibly lucky to get to play these shows here in New York, and this building means a lot to me,” he told the arena. “And two years ago today, I lost one of those friends.”

“It’s just about looking after each other.”

“I’m sure a lot of you have been through similar things. I hope you haven’t,” he added before picking up the guitar.

A song he wrote “about two years ago”

Styles set up the moment carefully: “There are so many people who have touched my life in such special ways that I wouldn’t be here without. I’m gonna play you a song I wrote for my friend about two years ago, if that’s all right.”

The gently melodic tune includes the lines, “I’m not wise enough / But I wrote you a letter just to burn it up / And watch it rise like you’re in the sky.”

Styles and Payne were original members of One Direction, from the group’s 2010 launch through its 2015 split. Rolling Stone posted a clip after the performance, and with the track still unreleased, that footage is the closest thing to an official listen.

Friday became the most personal night of the New York run so far: a song written privately “about two years ago” finally aired in public, less like a single than a eulogy for a friend.

More in the section Entertainment

Entertainment

Olivia Rodrigo is back at No. 1 as Thriller jumps to its highest spot in 40 years

Olivia Rodrigo's 'you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love' returns to No. 1 on the Billboard 200 for a fourth nonconsecutive week.

Entertainment

Sylvain Chomet: Dior film was 'entirely drawn by artists,' not AI

The 'Triplets of Belleville' director says his Dior holiday short used traditional 2D animation, after a six-fingered character sparked AI accusations.

Entertainment

Brad Pitt's Cliff Booth is back - and the new trailer finally shows the plot

The new trailer for The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth drops Booth into a 1977 Hollywood scheme with a star played by Scott Caan.

Entertainment

Travis Kelce 'can't wait' for first Christmas as a married man with Taylor Swift

The Chiefs tight end says he's ready to blend old traditions with new ones now that he's married to Taylor Swift.

Entertainment

Scarlett Johansson: her secret 'The Batman 2' role gave her 'existential angst'

The actress says her still-undisclosed role in The Batman: Part II was 'very hard to figure out' and left her with 'a lot of existential angst.'

Entertainment

Ariana Grande crashes her Focker-in-Law cast chat - and roasts a Booksmart reunion

The pop star popped into an on-set cast video and hugged Beanie Feldstein, telling the camera she loves the Booksmart trio.

Entertainment

Justin Timberlake's 'tell-all' docuseries will have Janet Jackson discuss the 2004 Super Bowl moment

A four-part docuseries arrives on Apple TV in December, with Janet Jackson speaking on the infamous 2004 Super Bowl 'wardrobe malfunction.'

Entertainment

Robert Downey Jr. and Pedro Pascal trade MCU roles in a playful Halloween costume swap

With Avengers: Doomsday weeks away, Robert Downey Jr. dressed as Mr. Fantastic while Pedro Pascal went as Dr. Doom in a paired costume.

Entertainment

Harry Styles recreated his 2010 X Factor audition at Harryween, bakery line and all

Styles swapped mid-show into the exact outfit from his teenage audition and covered Stevie Wonder's 'Isn't She Lovely' at Madison Square Garden.

Entertainment

Taylor Swift's 'I Knew It, I Knew You' tops the movie songs chart for a fourth month

Taylor Swift's Toy Story 5 cut logs a fourth straight month at No. 1 on Billboard's Top Movie Songs chart for September.

Lifestyle

Kylie Jenner made her LACMA debut in a shimmering deer-spot gown - it's fawn girl fall

Sport

Tank Dell scores first TD in 687 days as Texans receiver completes comeback from torn knee

Celebrity

Taylor Swift and Karlie Kloss reunite in Chiefs VIP suite after years-long feud

Food

Ocean Spray turned canned cranberry sauce into chocolate candy - $24.95 a box

Entertainment

Olivia Rodrigo is back at No. 1 as Thriller jumps to its highest spot in 40 years

Travel

Utah's national parks after dark: scorpion hunts, moonlit kayaks and star hikes

Lifestyle

Hailey Bieber swaps glazed nails for glossy black - and it's fall's biggest manicure

Sport

Messi sets up two as Inter Miami blow 3-0 lead but seal second in MLS

Celebrity

Prince William's blunt reason for splitting with Kate: 'I wanted to be sure'

Food

Dunkin' teams with General Mills on 3 coffee-flavored cereals for December

Entertainment

Sylvain Chomet: Dior film was 'entirely drawn by artists,' not AI

Travel

Legend of the Seas, world's largest cruise ship, makes U.S. debut this weekend

Lifestyle

Nicole Kidman's "Birkin" bangs were cut to feel like Sydney's salt air

Sport

Doc Rivers says Giannis 'doesn't have super IQ' and never wanted to be the bad guy

Celebrity

Billie Eilish's Halloween was a blue bob and head-to-toe latex as Noodle

Food

Turkuterie: a Bosc pear becomes a turkey-shaped cheese board in 30 minutes

Entertainment

Brad Pitt's Cliff Booth is back - and the new trailer finally shows the plot

Travel

Montreal is a gluten-free paradise - here's exactly where to eat

Lifestyle

Margot Robbie just debuted her sharpest, iciest bob yet

Sport

CeeDee Lamb blasts Cowboys offense: 'We stop ourselves. That sh*t is frustrating'