Harry Styles debuts 'What Is Enough' at MSG in moving Liam Payne tribute

Celebrity & Entertainment journalist
Harry Styles performing live on stage during his Together, Together tour
Harry Styles performing on the Together, Together tour Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0

Harry Styles marked the second anniversary of Liam Payne's death with a song nobody had heard before. On Friday night at Madison Square Garden, he introduced “What Is Enough,” an unreleased acoustic track, to a sold-out crowd during his Together, Together residency. Fans were hearing the song for the first time — not as a streaming release, but as a tribute played live.

Styles is in the middle of an MSG run that continues through October 31. Two years to the day since Payne died at 31 after falling from a balcony at the CasaSur Palermo Hotel in Buenos Aires, Argentina, he paused the show to address the packed room.

“I feel incredibly lucky to get to play these shows here in New York, and this building means a lot to me,” he told the arena. “And two years ago today, I lost one of those friends.”

“It’s just about looking after each other.”

“I’m sure a lot of you have been through similar things. I hope you haven’t,” he added before picking up the guitar.

A song he wrote “about two years ago”

Styles set up the moment carefully: “There are so many people who have touched my life in such special ways that I wouldn’t be here without. I’m gonna play you a song I wrote for my friend about two years ago, if that’s all right.”

The gently melodic tune includes the lines, “I’m not wise enough / But I wrote you a letter just to burn it up / And watch it rise like you’re in the sky.”

Styles and Payne were original members of One Direction, from the group’s 2010 launch through its 2015 split. Rolling Stone posted a clip after the performance, and with the track still unreleased, that footage is the closest thing to an official listen.

Friday became the most personal night of the New York run so far: a song written privately “about two years ago” finally aired in public, less like a single than a eulogy for a friend.

More in the section Entertainment

Entertainment

Olivia Rodrigo says Kendrick Lamar's 'HUMBLE.' inspired 'Expectations': 'It's a mantra'

Rodrigo reveals the Kendrick Lamar hit behind 'Expectations' as her Chappell Roan remix drops on streaming.

Entertainment

Jeff Goldblum and Colman Domingo join Benny Safdie's 'Lizard Music' voice cast

Jeff Goldblum, Colman Domingo, Rachel McAdams and David Krumholtz have boarded Benny Safdie's live-action/CGI film in voice roles.

Entertainment

Taylor Swift's 13 most autumnal songs, ranked by Billboard — led by 'All Too Well'

Billboard rounded up the 13 most fall-coded Taylor Swift songs, with 'All Too Well' as the crown jewel of the seasonal list.

Entertainment

Greta Gerwig's 'Narnia: The Magician's Nephew' trailer reveals Meryl Streep as Aslan

The first trailer for Gerwig's C.S. Lewis adaptation is here, with Led Zeppelin blasting as Aslan is born from cosmic dust.

Entertainment

Taylor Swift's 'Patient Zero' rules the Hot 100 again — her 51st week at No. 1

Taylor Swift holds at No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 for a second week with "Patient Zero," notching her 51st career week on top.

Entertainment

Todd Haynes says new Pedro Pascal film 'De Noche' will 'most likely' be R-rated

The director teased his long-awaited romance starring Pedro Pascal and Danny Ramirez at France's Lumière Festival.

Entertainment

Scarlett Johansson and Sam Rockwell sang 'Happy Birthday' to the Ray Gunn composer

Netflix's 'Ray Gunn' premiered in London on Michael Giacchino's birthday — so Brad Bird had Scarlett Johansson and Sam Rockwell sing him 'Happy Birthday.'

Entertainment

Cardi B, Troye Sivan and Eminem lead Billboard’s new music poll

Billboard’s latest New Music Friday poll puts Cardi B, Troye Sivan and Eminem in the mix, with Remi Wolf and Pitbull also in play.

Entertainment

Anne Hathaway gives Tom Cruise's flop 'Digger' a 10/10 on Letterboxd

Anne Hathaway has joined Tom Cruise's Digger defenders, rating the satirical disaster comedy a perfect 10/10 in her first-ever Letterboxd review.

Entertainment

Aerosmith returns for two Hollywood Bowl shows with Billy Idol, Slash and Run-D.M.C.

Aerosmith returns for two Hollywood Bowl nights — October 29 and November 1 — with Run-D.M.C., Billy Idol and Slash among the guests.

Celebrity

Miley Cyrus cries honoring Dolly Parton at Hollywood Bowl debut: 'We are eternal'

Lifestyle

Vogue's fall maximalism: ties, silk scarves and brooches piled to the neck

Travel

Île Seguin: Paris's former Renault island opens a 27,000-sq-ft art center

Sport

LeBron James more important to 76ers than Joel Embiid, says Kendrick Perkins

Food

Garofalo won a 9-brand boxed pasta blind test — and De Cecco is the budget pick

Entertainment

Olivia Rodrigo says Kendrick Lamar's 'HUMBLE.' inspired 'Expectations': 'It's a mantra'

Celebrity

Taylor Swift's viral glitter freckles now exist for dogs — Khloé's pup is first

Lifestyle

Kim Kardashian reworks the little black dress with a sculptural hip peplum

Travel

Waikiki's 'Pink Palace' is getting a major remodel ahead of its 100th birthday

Sport

Jayden Daniels: 'It'll never happen again' after Commanders' overtime clock gaffe

Food

Viral Dot Cakes are now at Costco — 6 sprinkle cakes for about $17

Entertainment

Jeff Goldblum and Colman Domingo join Benny Safdie's 'Lizard Music' voice cast

Celebrity

Selena Gomez wore two custom Prada gowns to host the Rare Impact Fund Gala

Lifestyle

Meghan Markle's first UK public outing: burgundy Joseph coat and a high-street pivot

Travel

Mediterranean cruises are now a winter thing — and prices are dropping

Sport

Fake 49ers star Daejon Love gets a Netflix 'Untold' doc called 'Wide Deceiver'

Food

Chips Ahoy & Heinz made a spicy tomato cookie — and China can't stop raving

Entertainment

Taylor Swift's 13 most autumnal songs, ranked by Billboard — led by 'All Too Well'

Celebrity

Sydney Sweeney wears dark brown wig at Santa Monica Pier — fans ask 'Hannah Montana?'

Lifestyle

H Mart's first cookbook is out — and it's organized like the store's aisles