Popeyes beats Chick-fil-A in chicken sandwich taste test, its second straight win

Celebrity & Entertainment journalist
A Popeyes classic chicken sandwich with a breaded fillet, pickles and mayo on a brioche bun
Popeyes chicken sandwich Wikimedia Commons / CC0

Few fast food rivalries are as competitive as the battle for the best chicken sandwich, and the chicken sandwich wars have a repeat champion. In a new Delish taste test, Popeyes' Classic Chicken Sandwich beat Chick-fil-A's Original Chicken Sandwich, giving Popeyes a second straight win after it knocked out KFC in the writer's previous comparison.

Writer Steven Morea ordered each chain's basic sandwich and judged flavor, texture, juiciness, and overall balance. Chick-fil-A has built its reputation on a simple, flavorful sandwich, and the Original stays minimal: a breaded chicken fillet, pickles, and a toasted bun, with no sauce anywhere. Morea praised a fillet with "savory, slightly tangy" flavor and "crispy breading," plus pickles that added "just enough acidity and crunch."

His complaint was what was missing. "My biggest complaint is that I wanted a little more from the sandwich," he wrote. "I think a little mayo or another sauce would have made the overall sandwich even better." The chicken was good enough to stand alone, he said, but next to a sauced-up rival the original "feels a bit plain."

Popeyes keeps its winning streak alive

Popeyes' Classic Chicken Sandwich layers a breaded fillet with pickles, mayo, and a toasted brioche bun. The sandwich that "practically broke the internet" when it launched in 2019 lived up to the hype this time, with a fillet that was "juicy, flavorful, and incredibly well-seasoned" and breading that "had a satisfying crunch." The mayo added "tangy creaminess," the pickles cut the richness, and every bite had a good balance of meat, breading, sauce, and pickles.

"When I'm ordering a chicken sandwich, I want the entire thing to work together, and that's where Popeyes has the advantage," Morea wrote. He gave Chick-fil-A credit for arguably the more distinctive chicken flavor, but said Popeyes delivered the better overall experience.

That's two wins in two showdowns for Popeyes, which beat KFC before clearing the Chick-fil-A bar. "Popeyes is proving to be a pretty tough sandwich to beat," Morea concluded.

More in the section Food

Food

Whipped cream at home: the one trick is beating with a side-to-side whisk

Cold cream, a bigger bowl than you think, and a side-to-side whisk - not circles - is all it takes for perfect peaks.

Food

Trader Joe's frozen lasagna beat Rao's and Stouffer's in a blind taste test

Bon Appetit cooked nine store-bought meat lasagnas from frozen. Here's which ones tasters would actually keep in the freezer.

Food

Glace's viral NYC hot chocolate is now a $20 at-home mix

The TikTok-famous S'mores Hot Chocolate from NYC's Glace now ships nationwide as a six-sachet mix for $19.99.

Food

Chex turned the PB&J sandwich into breakfast cereal, and fans are stocking up

General Mills is launching Chex Peanut Butter & Jelly Cereal, mixing strawberry- and peanut butter-flavored pieces in one box.

Food

Patrick Schwarzenegger says a frosted glass is what makes a great martini

After three years with Ketel One, the White Lotus actor says one small detail - a chilled glass - is what separates a good martini from a great one.

Food

Taco Bell's FLAMIN' HOT Mini Taco Salad underdelivers - the burrito brings heat

Taco Bell's new $2.49 Mini Taco Salad barely registers as spicy, but the returning $5.49 Grilled Cheese Burrito delivers a real FLAMIN' HOT kick.

Food

Taylor Ann Spencer tried GBBO's 'worst technical' flatbread - and lost to a smoking pan

Delish's Taylor Ann Spencer recreated the GBBO blue cheese and roasted grape flatbread under the show's 60-minute timer - and finished with three raw ones.

Food

McDonald's Holiday Pie is back for 2026 with custard and rainbow sprinkles

McDonald's Holiday Pie is back at select U.S. restaurants for the 2026 season, loaded with custard, sugar glaze and rainbow sprinkles.

Food

Bon Appétit's pecan cream pie uses sour cream twice - and that's the trick

Bon Appétit's new pecan cream pie layers a gooey nut base under brown sugar custard and whipped cream, with sour cream doing the heavy lifting.

Food

Taco Bell's Fire Piña Hot Dog uses a chalupa as the bun at Live Más Open

Taco Bell served a grilled-pineapple hot dog inside its signature chalupa flatbread at the Live Más Open, and fans who couldn't try it were horrified.

Entertainment

Olivia Rodrigo's 'Stupid Song' jumps to No. 1 on Billboard's Pop Airplay chart

Celebrity

Dolly Parton's niece wore a dress made for her unfinished video at the CMA Awards

Travel

How to walk England's South West Coast Path solo in 3 days - no tent

Sport

Chiefs GM Brett Veach: Patrick Mahomes' quick knee recovery 'didn't surprise' him

Lifestyle

Lady Gaga left yoga in Saint Laurent slingbacks - and carried bone broth

Food

Whipped cream at home: the one trick is beating with a side-to-side whisk

Entertainment

Brad Pitt's Cliff Booth returns in a Tarantino-Fincher hangout movie critics are loving

Travel

Dior opens its first Venice spa at Hotel Cipriani, with a 90-minute Mascarade facial

Sport

Travis Kelce on Falcons hit that sidelined him: 'That's football'

Lifestyle

Jennifer Lopez matched her nails and makeup to her all-burgundy outfit

Celebrity

Anne Hathaway pictured with newborn baby girl for the first time in NYC

Food

Trader Joe's frozen lasagna beat Rao's and Stouffer's in a blind taste test

Entertainment

Taylor Swift returns to the CMAs stage after 13 years - here's how to watch live

Travel

Seven Stars Resort & Spa is named the best resort in Turks and Caicos for 2026

Sport

Tiger Woods returns at the Hero World Challenge in December after two years away

Lifestyle

Bella Hadid's Aspen look: faux-fur coat, skinny jeans, vintage Chanel heels

Celebrity

Margaret Qualley leads Bond girl odds - but Florence Pugh wants the villain role

Food

Glace's viral NYC hot chocolate is now a $20 at-home mix

Entertainment

Only Murders in the Building season 6 trailer: the trio goes to London with big cameos

Travel

Which ski pass is best this winter: Epic, Ikon, Indy or the new $380 Snow Pass?